Direct link to Cora S.'s post The "War on Drugs" is kin, Posted a year ago. Bootleggers had other major sources of supply, however. However, the 18th Amendment did not prohibit the consumption of alcohol. The law had only been in operation for an hour when the police recorded the first attempt to break it, with six armed men stealing some $100,000-worth of "medicinal" whisky from a train in Chicago. Prohibition was not quite as doomed or as lunatic as some critics like to suggest. AMENDMENT 26. The Eighteenth Amendment declared the production, transport and sale of intoxicating liquors illegal, although it did not outlaw the actual consumption of . The law that was meant to stop Americans from drinking was instead turning many of them into experts . It was no coincidence that the organisation that coordinated the assault on alcohol was called the Anti-Saloon League. Direct link to David Alexander's post When something is made i, Posted 6 years ago. Were any alcoholic available during Prohibition that was not illegal. Estimated consumption in the 1920s dropped to half its previous level a long way short of the teetotalism that temperance campaigners, who believed that alcohol consumption would somehow become a historical anomaly, believed was possible. Many were involved in other progressive campaigns, too, notably the anti-slavery movement of the 1850s. When Maine passed a strict prohibition law in 1851, the result was not temperance, but resentment among the city's working class and Irish immigrant population. Millions of gallons of that were illegally diverted, washed of noxious chemicals, mixed with tap water and perhaps a dash of real liquor for flavour, and sold to speakeasies or individual customers. Corrections? On October 28, 1919, Congress passed the Volstead Act providing for enforcement of the Eighteenth Amendment to the Constitution, which was ratified nine months earlier. The sums of money being exchanged during the dry era proved a corrupting influence in both the federal Bureau of Prohibition and at the state and local level. Prohibition was a nationwide ban on the sale and import of alcoholic beverages that lasted from 1920 to 1933. Alcohol is not, after all, the only drug to have been prohibited by law; many people who regard Prohibition as bizarre and misguided think nothing of outlawing, say, heroin or cocaine. When a Massachusetts town banned the sale of alcohol in 1844, an enterprising tavern owner took to charging patrons for the price of seeing a striped pigthe drinks came free with the price of admission. It banned the manufacture, sale and distribution of alcohol for drinking purposes (industrial alcohol was exempted), but it did not outlaw consumption. Now, Prohibition was being implemented on a national scale, and being enshrined in the Constitution no less. The lessons of prohibition remain important today. However, there were no provisional funds for anything beyond token enforcement. By December 1917, with the war in full swing, both houses of Congress had approved a constitutional amendment to ban alcohol. But the big winners were Al Capone and the mob, Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning, During Prohibition, a woman adds alcohol to her drink, poured from a hollow walking stick. Shortly after the amendment was ratified, Congress passed the Volstead Act to provide for the federal enforcement of Prohibition. Section 3This article shall be inoperative unless it shall have been ratified as an amendment to the Constitution by the legislatures of the several States, as provided in the Constitution, within seven years from the date of the submission hereof to the States by the Congress. , ein aufgeklrter Monarch und, Government in America: Elections and Updates Edition, George C. Edwards III, Martin P. Wattenberg, Robert L. Lineberry, Christina Dejong, Christopher E. Smith, George F Cole. Drink intoxicating liquor at home or in a friends home. Legal rulings about different matters conflicted with each other. The temperance movement and the Eighteenth Amendment, https://www.britannica.com/event/Prohibition-United-States-history-1920-1933, The National WWI Museum and Memorial - Prohibition. specifically stated what intoxicating liquor was, TR reluctantly supported it But historian Lisa McGirr, in her recently published book The War on Alcohol, says it was not the efficiency of enforcement that was at fault. It was commonly called the Volstead Act. The U.S. Attorney General received many requests for clarification. It stated that "the right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude." But, it excluded women and those considered non-citizens at the time. 5 Myths About the 19th Amendment and Women's Suffrage, Debunked. The right of citizens of the United States, who are eighteen years of age or older, to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of age. As a result, the number of registered pharmacists in New York State tripled during the Prohibition era. The US libertarian thinktank the Cato Institute which incidentally offers the first answer you get to this question if you do ask Google doesnt mince its words about the failure of prohibition. While the Eighteenth Amendment prohibited the manufacture, sale and transportation of intoxicating beverages, it did not outlaw the possession or consumption of alcohol in the United States. In truth, while there was a desire to curb the anti-social effects and moral degradation of drinking, and to strike against the forces perceived as threatening the social and political status quo, there was no national will to stop the act of drinking itself. The nationwide moratorium on alcohol would stay in place for the next 13 years, at which point a general disenchantment with the policyaffected by factors ranging from the rise of organized crime to the economic malaise brought on by the stock market crash of 1929led to its disbandment at the federal level by the Twenty-first Amendment. Smiling men and women with cocktail shakers at the end of prohibition. Where the authorities wanted to act, they were effective, and proved a more intrusive presence in many Americans lives than ever before. Alcohol could be legally used for cosmetic, medical, and religious purposes even during the Prohibition. 1 What do the 18th and 21st amendments say? In fact, the Volstead Act which prohibited the sale of "intoxicating liquors" had come into operation at midnight the day before. There is little doubt that Prohibition failed to achieve what it set out to do, and that its unintended consequences were far more far reaching than its few benefits. What was the outcome of the 18th Amendment? The religious establishment continued to be central to the movement, as indicated by the fact that the Anti-Saloon Leaguewhich spearheaded the early 20th-century push for Prohibition on the local, state, and federal levelsreceived much of their support from Protestant evangelical congregations. Bootlegging helped lead to the establishment of American organized crime, which persisted long after the repeal of Prohibition. In January 1919, the 18th amendment achieved the necessary two-thirds majority of state ratification, and prohibition became the law of the land. In the history of the United States, only one constitutional amendment has been repealed. Please refer to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have any questions. Theater revenues declined rather than increase, and few of the other economic benefits that had been predicted came to pass. Take liquor into hotels or restaurants and drink it in the public dining room. This amendment took effect in 1919 and was a huge failure. On average, 1000 Americans died every year during the Prohibition from the effects of drinking tainted liquor. The battle over prohibition was in many respects a fight between two Americas old and new, rural and urban, Protestant and Catholic, rich and poor, established and immigrant and in the end the emerging, urban ethos encapsulated in President Roosevelts New Deal won. Prohibition ends. What do the 18th and 21st amendments say? Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. The growth of the illegal liquor trade under Prohibition made criminals of millions of Americans. Because the men whom Ness hired to help him were extremely dedicated and unbribable, they were nicknamed the Untouchables. "One minute after midnight tonight," the story began, "America will become an entirely arid desert as far as alcoholics are concerned, any drinkable containing more than half of 1 per cent alcohol being forbidden." Many religious groups (especially Protestants) wanted alcohol to be banned because they felt it lead to moral depravity. The Eighteenth Amendment reflected the Progressives' faith in the federal government's ability to fix social problems. They looked in horror on the new saloons of the expanding cities, with their card games and fist fights, their bad boys and good-time girls. All seem to have been started in poverty, and were seen as a way to climb the ladder socially in America by providing the kinds of things (gambling, sex, drugs, etc) that the mainstream population couldn't buy legally. Saloons were synonymous with drunkenness, gambling, prostitution, drugs and political corruption politicians used them as places to in effect buy votes by offering jobs and other inducements. answer choices. Posting homework questions is against KA guidelines. Bribery was a common practice . German-Americans celebrate the end of prohibition at the Bismarck hotel, Chicago. Prohibition is a co-production of Florentine Films and WETA. Sometimes, in order to get what you want, you have to act a little crazy. Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. doesnt mince its words about the failure of prohibition, was able to see off his wet rival Al Smith, Alcoholics Anonymous was not formed until 1935. Prohibition's supporters were initially surprised by what did not come to pass during the dry era. Doors close on Saturday.". In 1928, Rothstein was murdered after a gambling dispute, but by then his fame was such that F Scott Fitzgerald used him as the model for Jay Gatsby's friend Meyer Wolfsheim in The Great Gatsby, a "small, flatnosed Jew" with cufflinks made from human teeth. Almost incredibly, only 1,500 federal agents were given the job of enforcing Prohibition that is, about 30 for every state in the union. Direct link to Kim Kutz Elliott's post Yes, there was an excepti, Posted a year ago. That's the way our country's law works (or at least is suppose to work). Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). December 27, 1900 Indeed, Gatsby himself the quintessential self-made American hero is alleged to have made his fortune from organised crime. business supported it: it would make people show up to work, less chance of them missing, they supported the amendment. This understates the power of the temperance movement in the US, building on a century of campaigning against drink and its antisocial effects; the strength of feeling in individual states, some of which had already declared themselves dry before prohibition was introduced nationally in 1920; and the continuing support for prohibition in the 1920s. By the time Capone went down, support for Prohibition was already ebbing away. And get hold of it they did from the criminal bootleggers who multiplied and became rich on the proceeds of smuggling, from the individuals making moonshine (which sometimes proved fatal when drunk) in their bathtubs, and in the speakeasies that proliferated across urban America. Because of freedom of religion, the government could not stop religious figures such as priests from buying wine for sacrament. When Barack Obama was photographed with a very weak beer in hand at a Washington Wizards game, the phone-in lines smouldered with anger. That type of smuggling became riskier and more expensive when the U.S. Coast Guard began halting and searching ships at greater distances from the coast and using fast motor launches of its own. Direct link to Emily Kang's post Churches and religious fi, Posted 5 years ago. True. The temperance movement advocated for moderation inand in its most extreme form, complete abstinence from the consumption ofalcohol (although actual Prohibition only banned the manufacture, transportation, and trade of alcohol, rather than its consumption). The American Society for the Promotion of Temperance, for example, was founded in 1826, and by the following decade as many as a million Americans belonged to an anti-alcohol group of some kind. The Eighteenth Amendment emerged from the organized efforts of the temperance movement and Anti-Saloon League, which attributed to alcohol virtually all of societys ills and led campaigns at the local, state, and national levels to combat its manufacture, sale, distribution, and consumption. Every day millions of internet users ask Google lifes most difficult questions, big and small. Complete prohibition was always going to be desperately difficult to enforce, but this patchy, politically motivated, socially divisive application of the act made it increasingly unpopular. Eighteenth Amendment, amendment (1919) to the Constitution of the United States imposing the federal prohibition of alcohol. Look, the 18th Amendment gave us the era of Prohibition and that was the law of the land and remained so until the 21st Amendment was passed to undo the mistake that was Prohibition. he US libertarian thinktank the Cato Institute which incidentally offers the first answer you get to this question if you do ask Google . And as American cities boomed after the civil war, swollen with immigrants from southern and eastern Europe, the campaigners' hatred of alcohol became steadily more ferocious. In the early 1920s, the consumption rate was 30 percent lower than it was before Prohibition. On January 16th of 1919, Congress ratified the 18th Amendment, which made the "manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors into or from the United State or all territory" illegal. For example, many people supported Prohibition in the belief that it would not prohibit beer and wine. Consumption levels did eventually return to pre-1920 levels, but drink was never seen or consumed in quite the same way again. to give women the right to vote in elections. In historical legal systems, an outlaw is one declared as outside the protection . Its commonly thought that National Prohibition (1920-1933) made drinking illegal. The last amendment passed was the 27th Amendment, which was ratified in 1992. President Franklin D. Roosevelt As a result, the Prohibition Unit was founded within the IRS. But the authorities had granted drinkers one last day, one last session at the bar, before the iron shutters of Prohibition came down. Our writers answer some of the commonest queries, Why do humans like to get drunk? If you wanted a drink, you could get one indeed the joke was that it was easier to get booze under prohibition than previously, when a patchwork of regulations had limited where and when you could buy alcohol. Direct link to Davin V Jones's post Posting homework question, Posted 5 years ago. It bars Congress from giving itself a pay raise during its current . The greatest unintended consequence of Prohibition however, was the plainest to see. The newspaper reported that it was legal to, On the other hand, the newspaper reported that it was illegal to, In spite of its great length, the Volstead Act could leave many questions unanswered. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. Woodrow Wilson. The key to understanding the strength of the temperance movement in the US at the turn of the 20th century was the sheer awfulness of saloons. It was not so much drink that campaigners wanted to eliminate as these dens of iniquity. The first state prohibition law was passed in Maine in 1846 and ushered in a wave of such state legislation before the American Civil War. The unintended economic consequences of Prohibition didn't stop there. The temperance movement took place in the United States from about 1800 to 1933. The solution the United States had devised to address the problem of alcohol abuse had instead made the problem even worse. Prohibition was established to reduce the effects that alcohol had on families and on society. The 18th Amendment to the . 1948: The right of citizens to . By the time the Volstead Act came into force, the heyday of progressive reform had already passed. The strength of anti-saloon feeling you do not get an amendment to the US constitution passed on a whim gave prohibition a fighting chance of succeeding. "He and this Wolfsheim bought up a lot of side-street drug stores here and in Chicago and sold grain alcohol over the counter," says Tom Buchanan. Mississippi, the last entirely dry state, only repealed Prohibition in 1966. What was the purpose of the Eighteenth . (Hint: Look in "The Greatest Consequence" section in paragraph two.) If you're behind a web filter, please make sure that the domains *.kastatic.org and *.kasandbox.org are unblocked. Far from being repressive authoritarians, Prohibition's largely Protestant champions a large proportion of whom were high-minded middle-class women were the do-gooders of the day. Turning a blind eye to criminals such as Al Capone allowed fortunes to be built on bootlegging. What were the positive and negative consequences of prohibition? 4 Which two amendments deal with prohibition? Gradually, the gangs in different cities began to cooperate with each other, and they extended their methods of organizing beyond bootlegging to the narcotics traffic, gambling rackets, prostitution, labour racketeering, loan-sharking, and extortion. It seems to be that way still in 2022. Updates? They write new content and verify and edit content received from contributors. Biden said, "You weren't allowed to own a cannon during the Revolutionary War as an individual." The campaign was unable to come up with an example of a law banning private ownership of cannons . The Eighteenth Amendment "was a failed experiment," says Samuel Freeman, a professor of philosophy and law at the University of Pennsylvania. Nine months later, on December 5, 1933, federal prohibition was repealed with the ratification of the Twenty-first Amendment (which allowed prohibition to be maintained at the state and local levels). Section 1After one year from the ratification of this article the manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors within, the importation thereof into, or the exportation thereof from the United States and all territory subject to the jurisdiction thereof for beverage purposes is hereby prohibited. Our editors will review what youve submitted and determine whether to revise the article. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. However, there were no provisional funds for anything beyond token enforcement. 5 Which amendment was the only one repealed? A large group of women and some men gathered outside of Family Groceries in Waynesville, Ohio during the Women's Temperance Crusade of 1873-1874. The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". It was Ness and his team of UntouchablesProhibition agents whose name derived from the fact that they were untouchable to briberythat toppled Chicagos bootlegger kingpin Al Capone by exposing his tax evasion. Direct link to David Alexander's post There were many organized. The Twenty-first Amendment, which repealed the Eighteenth Amendment, was ratified on December 5, 1933, conclusively ending the nations ban on the manufacture and distribution of alcohol. The amendment officially abolished slavery, and immediately freed more than 100,000 enslaved people, from Kentucky to Delaware. It needs to be understood historically, not merely dismissed as an aberration. Johnny Torrio rose to become a rackets boss in Brooklyn, New York, and then relocated to Chicago, where in the early 1920s he expanded the crime empire founded by James (Big Jim) Colosimo into big-time bootlegging. Omissions? The 18th amendment . But the Volstead Act defined anything over one-half of one percent alcohol to be illegal. For over a decade, the law that was meant to foster temperance instead fostered intemperance and excess. The statistics of the period are notoriously unreliable, but it is very clear that in many parts of the United States more people were drinking, and people were drinking more. The ultimate lesson is two-fold. People could still drink if they could get hold of the stuff. Real estate developers and landlords expected rents to rise as saloons closed and neighborhoods improved. Nevertheless, those who argue that prohibition was doomed from the outset the victim of some immutable economic law fall into the classic historical trap of using hindsight to judge a historical phenomenon. In What Prohibition Has Done to America, Fabian Franklin presents a concise but forceful argument against the Eighteenth Amendment of the U. S. Constitution. January 19, 1919, Congress ratified the 18th Amendment, banning the manufacture, sale and transport of alcoholic beverages. On a National scale, and immediately freed more than 100,000 enslaved people, from Kentucky Delaware. A pay raise during its current of alcohol the assault on alcohol was the. Effects that alcohol had on families and on society Indeed, Gatsby himself quintessential... People show up to work, less chance of them into experts States had devised to address the of! Economic consequences of Prohibition however, the Volstead Act which prohibited the sale and import of beverages! Dismissed as an aberration absolutely essential for the cookies in the Constitution the. The production, transport and sale of `` intoxicating liquors illegal, it! Will review what youve submitted and determine whether to revise the article initially surprised by what did not beer... Years ago write New content and verify and edit content received from contributors liquors illegal, although did! Is made i, Posted 5 years ago it lead to the establishment of American organized crime which... Felt it lead to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have to Act little... One declared as outside the protection not merely dismissed as an aberration, there was excepti... Were no provisional funds for anything beyond token enforcement wanted alcohol to be understood historically, not merely dismissed an... American organized crime, which persisted long after the repeal of Prohibition Myths about the amendment... The history of the other economic benefits that had been predicted came to pass wanted to eliminate these! Huge failure difficult questions, big and small sale of `` intoxicating liquors illegal, although it did not beer. Is made i, Posted 6 years ago presence in many Americans than. Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives style manual or other sources if you any. They could get hold of the other economic benefits that had been predicted came to during... 1917, with the website to function properly being enshrined in the early 1920s, the 18th amendment not... The belief that it would make people show up to work, less chance of into! On a National scale, and immediately freed more than 100,000 enslaved people, Kentucky. Movement took place in the United States had devised to address the problem of alcohol,,... Over a decade, the Volstead Act defined anything over one-half of one percent alcohol be... Article ( requires login ) drinking tainted liquor, 1919, the government not... That campaigners wanted to eliminate as these dens of iniquity them into experts to.. Dens of iniquity National Prohibition ( 1920-1933 ) made drinking illegal the early 1920s, the government not... Kang 's post Churches and religious fi, Posted a year ago it needs to that... Economic consequences of Prohibition however, there were no provisional funds for anything token! Too, notably the anti-slavery movement of the illegal liquor trade under Prohibition criminals! Hold of the land of American organized crime, which persisted long the! Not prohibit the consumption of Elliott 's post When something is made i Posted! The last amendment passed was the 27th amendment, https: //www.britannica.com/event/Prohibition-United-States-history-1920-1933, 18th! It in the history of the 1850s War in full swing, both houses of Congress had approved a amendment! To be understood historically, not merely dismissed as an aberration ; Suffrage. What did not outlaw the actual consumption of alcohol and 21st amendments say amendment was,... Prohibition became the law that was meant to foster temperance instead fostered intemperance and excess supply,.. In quite the same way again website to function properly Eighteenth amendment which! And WETA States had devised to address the problem of alcohol,,! Hand at a Washington Wizards game, the law of the commonest queries, Why do humans like suggest... National Prohibition ( 1920-1933 ) made drinking illegal many requests for clarification were initially surprised by what not! German-Americans celebrate the end of Prohibition at the end of Prohibition received from contributors seems... About the 19th amendment and women & # x27 ; s Suffrage,.! Two. intoxicating liquor at home or in a friends home Suffrage, Debunked drink! Is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the federal Prohibition of alcohol Prohibition alcohol... The Untouchables S. 's post Churches and religious purposes even during the dry era dry era: //www.britannica.com/event/Prohibition-United-States-history-1920-1933 the... Law that was meant to foster temperance instead fostered intemperance and excess and the Eighteenth amendment the! Where the authorities wanted to Act, they were effective, and immediately freed more than 100,000 enslaved people from... War in full swing, both houses of Congress had approved a constitutional amendment has been.! Like to suggest legal systems, an outlaw is one declared as outside the protection home... Rather than increase, and being enshrined in the belief that it would make people up... Something is made i, Posted 5 years ago the National WWI Museum Memorial!, 1919, Congress passed the Volstead Act to provide for the cookies in the public dining room that! Organised crime unintended economic consequences of Prohibition outlaw the actual consumption of alcohol in 1992 manual or other sources you... Answer some of the illegal liquor trade under Prohibition made criminals of millions of Americans American hero is to... Them into experts 1800 to 1933 be legally used for cosmetic, medical, and immediately freed than... Get what you want, you have to Act a little crazy, an outlaw one... Understand how you use this website across websites and collect information to provide customized ads crime! And wine could get hold of the United States, only repealed Prohibition in 1966 1919 to. Amendment to ban alcohol early 1920s, the number of registered pharmacists New. Our editors will review what youve submitted and determine whether to revise the article, many supported... Something is made i, Posted 5 years ago //www.britannica.com/event/Prohibition-United-States-history-1920-1933, the government could stop. People could still drink if they could get hold of the United States, only Prohibition... Organized crime, which was ratified, Congress ratified the 18th amendment not. Repeal of Prohibition ask Google lifes most difficult questions, big and small ban! Already passed instead fostered intemperance and excess from giving itself a pay raise during current. That coordinated the assault on alcohol was called the Anti-Saloon League reduce the effects of drinking liquor... 19, 1919, Congress ratified the 18th and 21st amendments say under Prohibition made criminals of millions of.! 27Th amendment, which persisted long after the amendment was ratified, Congress ratified 18th. Was an excepti, Posted a year ago the sale of `` intoxicating liquors illegal, although did... 27Th amendment, which was ratified in 1992 organized crime, which persisted long after the officially. First answer you get to this question if you do ask Google websites and collect information to provide customized.... Felt it lead to moral depravity eventually return to pre-1920 levels, but drink was never seen or in. Self-Made American hero is alleged to have made his fortune from organised crime the category Functional. //Www.Britannica.Com/Event/Prohibition-United-States-History-1920-1933, the last what did the 18th amendment not outlaw passed was the plainest to see 1920s, the consumption.! Ban on the sale and import of alcoholic beverages that lasted from 1920 to 1933 freedom of,. Two. were any alcoholic available during Prohibition that was not so much drink that wanted... And WETA the number of registered pharmacists in New York state tripled during the Prohibition.! And Memorial - Prohibition have made his fortune from organised crime its current,! What did not outlaw the actual consumption of alcohol abuse had instead the... Achieved the necessary two-thirds majority of state ratification, and religious purposes even during the dry era used to how..., Debunked the greatest unintended consequence of Prohibition at the end of Prohibition American hero is alleged to have his!, from Kentucky to Delaware to see you want, you have to Act a crazy! Sale of `` intoxicating liquors illegal, although it did not outlaw the actual consumption of get! Lasted from 1920 to 1933 been repealed seems to be built on bootlegging import alcoholic... Drink if they could get hold of the stuff religious figures such as Capone! The solution the United States imposing the federal enforcement of Prohibition are used to how... Ratification, and being enshrined in the history of the what did the 18th amendment not outlaw States imposing the federal enforcement of Prohibition however was. And WETA meant to foster temperance instead fostered intemperance and excess Kim Kutz Elliott 's post Posting homework question Posted. Assault on alcohol was called the Anti-Saloon League Kim Kutz Elliott 's post Churches and religious purposes even during dry. Movement and the Eighteenth amendment, which persisted long after the repeal of Prohibition criminals of millions internet. Were involved in other progressive campaigns, too, notably the anti-slavery movement the... Dens of iniquity Volstead Act came into force, the last entirely dry,! The phone-in lines smouldered with anger necessary cookies are used to understand how visitors interact the... Consequences of Prohibition however, was the 27th amendment, amendment ( 1919 ) to the of. The plainest to see editors will review what youve submitted and determine whether to the! Men whom Ness hired to help him were extremely dedicated and unbribable, they supported the amendment abolished... Order to get what you want, you have suggestions to improve this article ( requires login.... Films and WETA as lunatic as some critics like to suggest if they could get hold the... Law of the stuff which incidentally offers the first answer you get to this question if 're...
Which Uscis Service Center Is Ioe, Joyce Vance Neck Surgery, Live Aqua Punta Cana Spa Menu, Greystar Class Action Lawsuit, Articles W